What is Probate Law: 5 Toxic Reasons Why Relatives May Contest Your Will – and How You Can Prevent it

Preparing a will now is the only way to ensure your last wishes for loved ones and beneficiaries will be met, particularly regarding distribution of your property and estate. Understanding Probate Litigation can help you ensure your will won’t be contested.

No one wants to spend time thinking about their own death, but not doing so can leave your family and loved ones in a very difficult position over and above the extreme grief and emotional turmoil they may feel at the time of your passing.

There are a lot of reasons why a person’s will may be contested, but in order to avoid this and to secure peace of mind for yourself, and later for your loved ones, it is important to take steps right now to eliminate the chance of your last wishes being undermined.

Here are the five most common reasons wills are contested and steps you can take to ensure yours is upheld.

1. Your Kids May Secretly Believe You Are Insane

As people age, many will experience some form of mental capacity depreciation. But certainly not all will experience senility or dementia. The problem is, if you don’t prepare your will now, while you are of sound mind, your will could be contested on the basis that when it was drafted, the testator (you) was lacking full mental capacity.

Your children may not outright claim you were insane (although they might); but they could try to prove you did not understand the consequences of making the will at the time of its creation. Aside from various illness’ which can affect one’s thinking capacity, they may also claim you were under the influence of drugs or alcohol, or a religious delusion, having no foundation in reality.

To win such a claim, not only would they need to prove that upon signing your will you were indeed exhibiting lack of mental capacity as listed above, but that as a result of it you did not understand the following:

  • The extent and value of the estate;
  • Whom you are expected to provide for and whom your beneficiaries will be;
  • The disposition you are making and what a will actually means;
  • How these elements correlate to form a distribution of your property.

2. A Master Manipulator Is Pulling the Wool Over Your Eyes

If someone proves that the intentions of your will are the result of undue influence or duress, it can be contested and invalidated. It is best to be certain you draft your will in a manner that will not leave people concerned you were being manipulated or forced to sign over your estate due to undue pressure or influence.

To avoid having your will contested under this category, here are a few things to make sure of when drafting your copy:

  • Beneficiaries should not be present when your will is executed nor when you discuss your intentions;
  • The probate lawyer preparing the will should not be from a referral by a beneficiary;
  • Beneficiaries should not know the contents of the will;
  • Beneficiaries should not provide instructions to the attorney;
  • Beneficiaries should not provide the witnesses for the will signing;
  • Beneficiaries should not have possession of the will after its execution.

3. Provision for Dependents and Spouse: Keeping it Fair

If your dependents or spouse have been disinherited or believe they are not receiving their fair share of your estate, they may choose to contest your will.

There are many plausible reasons why you may not wish to distribute your property equally, but here is a list of things to avoid, if you don’t want your beneficiaries to undergo the expense and inconvenience of Probate Litigation:

  • Dividing the estate unequally between the children and/or grandchildren;
  • Excluding certain children from any part of the estate, while awarding the lion’s share to another;
  • If you plan to provide gifts and property to unexpected or unrelated people, be sure your beneficiaries and your lawyers are aware of this, so they know it is your true intention.

Another way to prevent family property allocation squabbles is to establish a living trust which appoints survivorship rights of property such as life insurance, pension proceeds or real estate to a joint party whom will assume the assets automatically upon death. These need not be mentioned in the will and are not disputable.

4. Fraud and Forgery: How a Discarded Bag of Doritos Chips Cost This Woman a £550,000 Inheritance

Fraud and forgery of your will may be difficult for your beneficiaries to prove because you will no longer be available as the first-hand witness to provide evidence to back up such claims.

In some cases, however, it is just plain obvious.

An entertaining story of a young woman found guilty of will forgery hit the newsstands in England
in 2017. She was in her thirties married to an 86-year old man and was left only £25,000 of his £600,000 estate. Shortly thereafter, she contested the will claiming to have found a “more recent” copy stored in the attic in a discarded Doritos bag. This “new” will awarded her with £550,000 and left only a few thousand for the other beneficiaries.

The story sounded ridiculous, but the judge did his due diligence before denying probate litigation. It wasn’t the nonsensical story of the Doritos bag that cost her the judge’s ruling, but the other obvious errors including the size of the document and the wording which called the document “her” last will and testament, rather than “his”.

Proving fraud or forgery may be difficult for your true beneficiaries, so it is important to avoid some aspects in your will which may seem suspicious of such felonies. Some of these include:

  • Excluding a spouse or child with no obvious reason;
  • Leaving a large bequest to whomever drafted the will;
  • Excluding an expected beneficiary in order to benefit another;
  • Leaving your estate and property to primarily non-relatives;
  • Executing multiple wills leading up to death.

5. Your Signature or Handwriting Style Could Render Your Will Null and Void

If your will is not written, signed and filed according to the State Laws applicable to your place of residence, there may be grounds for someone to contest it.

Although these may seem like minor details, compliance with these formalities can be the difference between having a valid estate plan or your beneficiaries engaging in costly probate litigation.

A valid will has to be in writing, has to be signed by the testator in the presence of two or more witnesses present at the same time, and it has to be signed by those two or more witnesses. As a safeguard for the witnesses to avoid having to attend court at a later time, often a public notary is present when the witnesses sign the document.

Improper Execution of the will (overlooking these technical formalities) can result in significant delays in administering the estate and significant costs as a result of protracted litigation.

In most states, however, if you choose, you can draft your entire will in handwriting and as such will not need to have witnesses present. This is referred to as a holograph will. Holograph wills are the most likely to be contested as there are no witnesses, so if you hope to avoid your will being contested, this is not a good way to go.

Should a holograph will be contested, the validity of the words therein are at the mercy of a handwriting specialist whom will compare the document to other handwriting samples in order to identify the writer, the psychological state at the time of writing and an evaluation of their personal characteristics.

Probate Law is about more than just wills and estates, but when it comes to contesting a will, or avoiding your family or loved ones from contesting yours, this is the legal process you will turn to ensure your last wishes will be executed smoothly. For help from a Probate Law Expert, contact California’s finest attorneys for a free consultation. Call 949-514-8605 or visit Sadeghi & Associates
to book an appointment today.

Have you been involved with a Will and Testament dispute? Are you thinking about drafting your first will and are curious to learn more about what is Probate Law? Please leave a comment below to share your experiences and questions.


Share this story

Post a comment